The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) voted today to approve a regulation that will reinstate net neutrality rules, allowing the agency to regulate broadband internet access as a telecommunications service.
These net neutrality rules were initially introduced during the Obama administration in 2015 but were repealed in 2017 under the Trump administration. The repeal shifted control of the FCC, resulting in broadband internet being regulated as an information service. With the Biden administration now overseeing the FCC, a majority of Democratic appointees have led to the reinstatement of net neutrality rules, bringing broadband regulation back under Title II of the Communications Act.
Ahead of the FCC’s 3-2 vote, Chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel, a Biden appointee, emphasized the importance of a national net neutrality policy. She stated that clear regulations are beneficial for consumers, public safety, and national security.
However, FCC Commissioner Brendan Carr, a Republican appointee, opposed the measure, calling it a “power grab.” He expressed concerns about the government granting itself more powers to intervene in internet-related decisions.
Carr noted that previous concerns raised by net neutrality supporters during the 2017 repeal did not materialize, citing improvements in internet speeds and reductions in prices since then.
Regarding arguments for reinstating net neutrality, Carr mentioned concerns about national security and privacy rules. He argued that existing agencies, such as the Department of Homeland Security and the Federal Trade Commission, already address these issues.
Carr warned that while consumers may not immediately notice changes, reinstating net neutrality could hinder industry investment in innovation and product enhancements in the long run.
He also predicted legal challenges to the FCC’s decision, expecting the regulation to be struck down in court. Carr expressed confidence that the Supreme Court would overturn the decision, citing skepticism about agencies expanding their powers beyond what Congress intended.
The future of net neutrality regulations is likely to be shaped by ongoing legal battles and evolving policies at the FCC.